Checking a used machine's accuracy before buying

Buying · · 5 min read

DMG MORI DMC 635 V – view 1

Listening to the spindle and checking the axes for backlash tells you about the condition of a machine tool. To know what it can really hold, you need to go further: measure its accuracy with standardised methods, then compare the results with reference values. These measurements call for specific instruments and know-how. This article presents the test standards, the instruments used, test pieces and how to read the results.

The reference standards

ISO 230, the test code for machine tools

ISO 230 is divided into parts, each dedicated to one type of test. The main ones:

  • ISO 230-1: geometric accuracy of machines operating under no-load or quasi-static conditions;
  • ISO 230-2: accuracy and repeatability of positioning of numerically controlled axes;
  • ISO 230-3: determination of thermal effects;
  • ISO 230-4: circular tests for numerically controlled machine tools;
  • ISO 230-7: geometric accuracy of axes of rotation.

Standards by machine type

Other standards build on ISO 230 and apply it to a family of machines:

  • ISO 10791 for machining centers. Part 7 describes test pieces and sets tolerances for general-purpose, normal-accuracy machining centers with horizontal or vertical spindles. It also applies, fully or partly, to NC milling and boring machines with a compatible configuration.
  • ISO 13041 for NC turning machines and turning centers. Part 6 describes cutting tests under finishing conditions on standard test pieces.

Geometry: ISO 230-1

Geometric tests are carried out with the machine under no load or quasi-static conditions, without cutting forces. They cover straightness of travel, squareness between axes, parallelism and the alignment of the spindle with the axes. Traditional tools are dial indicators, precision levels and reference artefacts such as straightedges and test squares. The laser interferometer, described below, also measures straightness and squareness.

Positioning: ISO 230-2

To assess positioning accuracy and repeatability, each axis is moved to a series of defined positions and the position actually reached is measured, with repeated measurements. Accuracy describes the deviation between programmed and actual position; repeatability, the axis's ability to return to the same point.

The reference instrument is the laser interferometer. It produces a very stable beam whose wavelength is traceable to national and international standards. Depending on the optics, it measures linear, angular, straightness and squareness errors, and with a dedicated accessory, the errors of rotary axes. Air temperature, pressure and humidity affect the wavelength: an environmental compensator corrects for them. The results can also feed the compensation tables of the CNC control.

Grid encoders, which measure in the working plane, are another option: they are used for positioning tests to ISO 230-2, thermal tests and circular tests.

Circular tests and the ballbar: ISO 230-4

A ballbar is a telescoping linear sensor with a precision ball at each end. Mounted between the spindle and a fixture on the table, it measures variations in radius while the machine follows a programmed circle. The deviations reveal geometric, dynamic or play-related errors. Reports can be produced to ISO 230-4, and most of the tests in ISO 10791-6 can be carried out with this type of device.

The circle radius changes what you see: large radii mainly reveal the machine's geometry, small radii its dynamic behaviour under high axis acceleration.

Thermal drift: ISO 230-3

A machine that heats up deforms. Frictional heat in the ball screws affects positioning accuracy, especially when position is measured only by the motor encoder, without a linear scale. Tests to ISO 230-3 analyse this behaviour by repeatedly positioning the axis to two points within its travel. In practice, a measurement taken on a cold machine does not tell the whole story: compare it with one taken after a period of operation.

Test pieces

Machining a test piece remains a concrete way of judging a machine. ISO 10791-7 defines cutting tests under finishing conditions on standard test pieces, specifying their characteristics and dimensions, for machining centers with 3 to 5 simultaneous axes. An annex adds a freeform test piece, machined by flank milling, for 5-axis machining centers. ISO 13041-6 plays the same role for lathes.

A test piece has its limits, however: a defect can come from the tool, a worn spindle or the clamping as much as from the machine itself, and a part of one shape tells you little about parts of a different shape. Direct measurements, laser and ballbar, help locate the source of a deviation.

Comparing results with acceptance values

  • Tolerances in the standards: ISO 10791-7 sets maximum acceptable values for general-purpose, normal-accuracy machining centers.
  • The manufacturer's acceptance report: if it exists, it gives the values measured on delivery. To compare, repeat the same tests under the same conditions: same method, same radius and feed rate for a ballbar, same thermal state of the machine.
  • Your own tolerances: a machine that no longer meets its original values may still suit you if your parts ask for less.

At Fimotec

Each machine page in our stock shows the specifications recorded on the machine, its control and, when available, the manufacturer's data with their origin, for example for this DMG MORI DMC 635 V machining center. The price is given on request, transport and installation can be arranged on request, and every enquiry receives an answer within 48 working hours: contact Fimotec.

Further reading

A question about a machine?

Write or call us: answer within 48 working hours.

Contact us